"Express Yourself" -- But Not in Duesseldorf
---
(Cross-posted previously at Overlawyered.)
One of the points that I often emphasize is that there simply is no First Amendment in Europe.
Just ask Madonna:
Of course, we have our own "freedom of artistic expression" problems here in the U.S., most of which can be summed up in three letters: FCC. And there is still a small smattering of Robert Bork acolytes who preposterously insist that the First Amendment doesn't apply to art.
A successful artist such as Madonna already needs enough lawyers to put on a mega-concert. She shouldn't need a criminal defense counsel too.
UPDATE: German prosecutors took no action.
---
And if you think Europe is bad, then try Africa:
One of the points that I often emphasize is that there simply is no First Amendment in Europe.
Just ask Madonna:
Prosecutors plan to keep an eye on Madonna's weekend concert in Duesseldorf to see if the pop diva repeats the mock crucifixion scene that has drawn fire from religious leaders.Read that again: "might be covered." So not only is there no blanket freedom of expression, but what partial protections do exist are so vague that even the prosecutors don't know how they apply to whom under what circumstances.
Johannes Mocken, a spokesman for prosecutors in Duesseldorf, said Tuesday that a repeat of that scene during Sunday's concert could be construed as insulting religious beliefs.
...
Mocken said authorities would rely on media reports rather than sending observers to the concert and that the show might be covered by laws protecting artistic freedoms.
Of course, we have our own "freedom of artistic expression" problems here in the U.S., most of which can be summed up in three letters: FCC. And there is still a small smattering of Robert Bork acolytes who preposterously insist that the First Amendment doesn't apply to art.
A successful artist such as Madonna already needs enough lawyers to put on a mega-concert. She shouldn't need a criminal defense counsel too.
UPDATE: German prosecutors took no action.
---
And if you think Europe is bad, then try Africa:
A Zimbabwean man is in police custody after allegedly making insulting remarks about President Robert Mugabe.I guess there are no Bush-style "free speech zones" in Zimbabwe. Go figure.
Tichaona Muchabaiwa was arrested at the weekend at a police roadblock, the official Herald newspaper reports.
...
He is to be charged under a law that makes it illegal to "undermine the authority of or insult the president," a police spokesman said.
All Related Posts (on one page) | Some Related Posts:
- "It is a System that is Part Kafka and Part Stalin"
- Italy Jumps the Censorship Shark With Blogger Registry Plan
- No First Amendment in Europe -- U.K. School Bans "Purity Rings"...
- UK Jews Arrested for Anti-Semitism, But Anti-Israel Constable Accommodated
- "Express Yourself" -- But Not in Duesseldorf
- Still More "No First Amendment in Europe" Reports...
- Historian Faces 20 Years for Holocaust Denial
- U.K. Requires Alcohol Companies to Use Ugly Models
- Please Don't Read this Post in Poland!
Posted by Kip on
15 August 2006
To comment on this post, please visit the new blogsite.



