The Politics of the Warm Fuzzy Feeling Smoking Age
---
New York hack politician seeks to raise the state's smoking age to 19:
I see little need to analyze this nonsense any deeper than the standard "an adult who can vote, own a gun and serve in the military should obviously have the right to buy a pack of cigarettes."
On the other hand, as a gay I find the politics of this maneuver strangely familiar. Although no one is 18 forever, 18-year olds, as a group, are a permanent minority, with little if any political power. So it's easy for hack politicians to infringe their rights for some vague, self-proclaimed "majoritarian" purpose. Yup, that definitely sounds familiar.
And I as asked in this post earlier today, is it really somehow less wise to be governed, at least in part, by unelected judges than by elected morons like this?
The Senate Health Committee is expected tomorrow to consider the bill, which is sponsored by the same senator, [Republican] Charles Fuschillo...who sponsored the statewide ban on smoking in most indoor public places.And here at A Stitch in Haste we have a name for that: The Politics of the Warm Fuzzy Feeling. The politicians "did something." The fact that it was something stupid and useless is becoming increasingly irrelevant.
...
Three states -- Alabama, Utah and Alaska -- have raised the tobacco-purchasing age to 19.
...
Fuschillo said the goal of his bill is to make it more difficult for high-school kids to get their hands on cigarettes. Many younger teens, he said, use 18-year-old school friends to buy cigarettes for them. Raising the age by a year will greatly diminish that option, he said.
...
Conservative Party Chairman Michael Long, who quit smoking eight years ago, branded the bill as nothing more than "feel-good, politically correct legislation that really won't do anything."
I see little need to analyze this nonsense any deeper than the standard "an adult who can vote, own a gun and serve in the military should obviously have the right to buy a pack of cigarettes."
On the other hand, as a gay I find the politics of this maneuver strangely familiar. Although no one is 18 forever, 18-year olds, as a group, are a permanent minority, with little if any political power. So it's easy for hack politicians to infringe their rights for some vague, self-proclaimed "majoritarian" purpose. Yup, that definitely sounds familiar.
And I as asked in this post earlier today, is it really somehow less wise to be governed, at least in part, by unelected judges than by elected morons like this?
All Related Posts (on one page) | Some Related Posts:
Posted by KipEsquire on
9 May 2005
To comment on this post, please visit the new blogsite.



